#
AGAIN OPPOSE BILL SHIELDING LAWMAKERS -
Senate Law No. 280, 2016 - Agenda Brazil 2015 AND
MARINE LE PEN AND TRUMP CONGRATULATIONS
Senate Law No. 280, 2016 - Agenda Brazil 2015 AND
MARINE LE PEN AND TRUMP CONGRATULATIONS
[ENGLISH VERSION]
SOURCE / LINK:
http://g1.globo.com/jornal-nacional/noticia/2017/04/ministro-marco-aurelio-do-stf-critica-project-sobre-abuso-de-autoridade.html
Minister Marco Aurélio, of
the Federal
Supreme Court
(STF) ,
criticizes Abuse of Authority (oppose bill shielding
lawmakers –
Senate
Law
No. 280, 2016 - Agenda Brazil 2015)
Rapporteur Roberto Requião
delivered the text to the Senate under criticism.
Renan in the tribune
attacked the Public Prosecutor's Office and Operation Car Wash.
Minister Marco Aurélio of
the Federal Supreme Court (S.T.F) criticized the abuse
of authority bill of law presented on Wednesday (19) by
the rapporteur - senator Roberto Requião - of the Brazilian
Democratic
Movement Party (PMDB)
of
Paraná. In the Senate, Renan Calheiros
defended the report.
The PMDB leader in the
Senate once again occupied the rostrum to attack the Public
Prosecutor's Office and Operation Car Wash.
Renan Calheiros is guilty
in a lawsuit in the Supreme Court and responds to 16 inquiries, 13 in
Operation
Car Wash, five of which
are related to Odebrecht's allegations. He is the politician with the
largest number of inquiries in the Federal Supreme Court.
Renan criticized the
award-winning pleas and accused Operation Car Wash prosecutors of
abuse of authority.
"We witnessed the
poisoning of democracy by the provocation to demoralize good
public men, condemned even before the lawsuit was instituted,
facing the elected power. This is the great deception of the
moralistic crusades. The generalization leaves marks on innocent
people and abuses undermine fundamental rights, "said Senator
Renan Calheiros (PMDB-Alagoas State - AL), leader of the party.
Senator Roberto Requião of
the PMDB, who was appointed by Renan Calheiros to be the rapporteur
for the abuse of authority project, said that he included in the
proposal many of the suggestions of the Attorney General, Rodrigo
Janot, and that he receives criticism from those who do not wants to
be punished for the abuses he commits.
Delegates, prosecutors and
judges are mainly concerned with two points of the project. One
authorizes the defendants' attorneys to file suit for abuse of
authority against them, for example, by arresting a suspect. And the
other allows judges and prosecutors to be punished for interpreting
the law.
Senator Ana Amelia, of the
Progressive Party, also questioned in plenary the change of Requião.
"Now, in this specific
issue of interpretation, the response from your excellency has not
left me sufficiently calm about the risks that Operation Car Wash
runs, yes," said Senator Ana Amélia (PP-RS).
Senator Álvaro Dias
criticized the speech of Renan Calheiros. "This is not the time
to question the conduct of investigators and judges. This is the time
to question the conduct of public officials who have practiced
corruption, "said Sen. Alvaro Dias (Green Party PV-Parana State
PR), the leader of the party.
The passing of a law that
punishes judges by interpretation of the law also worries ministers
of the Supreme.
Minister Marco Aurélio
Mello said that hermeneutics - the interpretation of the law - is a
fundamental part of the work of the magistrates.
"We do not have a
hermeneutic crime, for the interpretation given by the judge, by the
body invested in the judicial office," said Marco Aurélio, STF
minister.
When asked about punishment
for a judge who interprets the law: "Certainly, I would go to
the firing squad."
topics:
Marco Aurélio Mello,
Odebrecht,
PMDB,
PP,
Rodrigo Janot,
Federal Court of Justice
See too
Cunha speaks on
'intervention' of the STF and says that it will resort to remoteness
5/6/2016
Fachin's list has 39
deputies, including the mayor of
04/04/2017
Janot presents alternative
proposal to abuse of authority project
03/29/2017
List of Janot arrives at
the Lava Jato rapporteur on the Supreme
03/22/2017
MENU
G1
News
- Updated
==//==
Sunday,
April 23, 2017 Nisan 27, 5777 10:27 am IDT
Home
>
'Whoever
is the toughest on radical Islamic terrorism, and whoever is the
toughest at the borders, will do well in the election'
Trump: Paris killing will ‘probably help’ Le Pen in France
Ahead of closest presidential race in memory, US president says shooting will boost far-right candidate, but notes he’s not endorsing her
By AP
and Times
of Israel staff April 21, 2017, 10:21 pm
A composite image showing French presidential
candidate and Front National leader, Marine Le Pen, left,
(AFP/Lionel Bonaventure) and US President Donald Trump, right
(AP/Alex Brandon).
Newsroom
Related Topics
Related Stories
President
Donald Trump waded into France’s upcoming elections Friday,
saying he believes an attack on police officers this week will help
Marine Le Pen, the far-right presidential candidate.
In
an interview with The Associated Press, Trump said that while he is
not explicitly endorsing Le Pen, the attack played to her
strengths.
“She’s
the strongest on borders, and she’s the strongest on what’s
been going on in France,” Trump said in the Oval Office
interview. “Whoever is the toughest on radical Islamic terrorism,
and whoever is the toughest at the borders, will do well in the
election.”
US
presidents typically avoid weighing in on specific candidates
running in overseas election. But Trump suggested his opinion was
no different from an average observer, saying, “Everybody is
making predictions on who is going to win. I’m no different than
you.”
Sunday’s
vote is the first round in the French elections, with the top two
candidates advancing to a winner-takes-all runoff on May 7. The
high-stakes contest is viewed as something of a vote on the future
of the European Union, with Le Pen calling for a referendum on
France’s membership in the bloc.
Le
Pen has also echoed some of Trump’s hard-line rhetoric on
immigration, calling for hardening French borders to stanch what
she describes as an out-of-control flow of immigrants.
She
has spoken of radical Muslims trying to supplant France’s
Judeo-Christian heritage and, among other measures, has called for
foreigners suspected of extremism to be expelled from the country.
Le
Pen, a 48-year-old mother of three, has distanced herself from her
father, National Front party founder Jean-Marie Le Pen, who has
been convicted of crimes related to anti-Semitism and mocked the
Holocaust as a “detail” of history.
Nevertheless,
earlier this month she denied the French state was responsible for
the roundup of Jews during World War II, drawing condemnation from
other presidential candidates and Israel’s Foreign Ministry. And
her inner circle still includes old friends from her student days
in Paris who were members of a radical group known for violence and
anti-Semitism.
Former
President Barack Obama has also gotten involved in France’s
election, offering centrist candidate Emmanuel Macron his best
wishes in a phone call Thursday, though he, too, stopped short of a
full endorsement.
Macron’s
team released a video recording of the call, a highly unusual move
as conversations among different countries’ politicians are
usually kept private.
A
victory for Macron would be a vote of confidence in France staying
in the EU. Obama, when he was in office, encouraged Britain not to
leave, though it ultimately voted to do so anyway.
Trump
backed Britain’s decision to exit from the EU and has also
predicted that other countries would make similar decisions. Yet
during a White House news conference Thursday, the president said
he believed in a strong Europe.
“A
strong Europe is very, very important to me as president of the
United States,” he said.
Trump
said he believed Thursday’s attack in Paris’s Champs-Elysees
district that left a police officer dead would “probably help”
Le Pen.
France’s
anti-terrorism prosecutor said Friday the gunman had a note with
him defending the Islamic State group.
Earlier,
the US president tweeted that the attack, claimed by the Islamic
State, “will have a big effect” on the vote.
Police
seal off the Champs-Elysees avenue in Paris, France, after a fatal
shooting in which a police officer was killed along with an
attacker, Thursday, April 20, 2017. (AP Photo/Thibault Camus)
“Another
terrorist attack in Paris. The people of France will not take much
more of this. Will have a big effect on presidential election!”
Trump
tweeted hours after a gunman, identified as 39-year-old Karim
Cheurti, shot dead a policeman and wounded two others on the
world-famous Champs-Elysees boulevard.
The
attack rocked France’s presidential race Friday with just days to
go before one of the closest elections in recent memory.
Meanwhile,
French Prime Minister Bernard Cazeneuve on Friday accused Le Pen of
seeking to use the attack for political gain.
Cazeneuve,
a Socialist, said Le Pen’s National Front (FN) “after each
attack, seeks to exploit it and use it for purely political means.”
France
is in a state of emergency and at its highest possible level of
alert since a string of terror attacks that began in 2015, which
have killed over 230 people.
The
swift claim by IS indicated the group may have been trying to
capitalize on the widespread attention from a high-profile attack
at a time when Islamic extremism and security are at the center of
France’s presidential campaign.
The Times of Israel
Daily Edition
Free to Your Inbox
-
Most
Home
Israel
& the Region Jewish
Times Israel
Inside The
Blogs The
Jewish Planet Start-Up
Israel Daily
Edition Spotlight
© 2017 The Times of
Israel, All rights reserved.
Concept, design &
development by
Powered by
==//==
[PORTUGUESE VERSION]
29/03/2017
22/03/2017
-
Atualizado em
Ministro Marco Aurélio, do STF, critica projeto sobre abuso de autoridade
Relator
Roberto Requião entregou o texto ao Senado sob críticas.
Renan
na tribuna atacou Ministério Público e a Operação Lava Jato.
O
ministro Marco Aurélio, do Supremo
Tribunal Federal,
criticou o projeto de abuso de autoridade apresentado na
quarta-feira (19) pelo relator - senador Roberto Requião - do PMDB
do Paraná. No Senado, Renan Calheiros defendeu o relatório.
O
líder do PMDB
no Senado ocupou a tribuna mais uma vez para atacar o Ministério
Público e a Operação Lava Jato.
Renan
Calheiros é réu em um processo no Supremo e responde a 16
inquéritos, 13 na Lava Jato, sendo cinco relacionados às delações
da Odebrecht.
É o político com o maior número de inquéritos no Supremo
Tribunal Federal.
Renan
criticou as delações premiadas e acusou os procuradores da Lava
Jato de abuso de autoridade.
“Presenciamos
o envenenamento da democracia pelo açodamento em desmoralizar
homens públicos de bem, condenados antes mesmo do processo se
instaurar, afrontando o poder eleito. Este é o grande engodo das
cruzadas moralistas. A generalização deixa marcas em inocentes e
abusos soterram direitos fundamentais”, disse o senador Renan
Calheiros (PMDB-AL), líder do partido.
O senador Roberto Requião, do PMDB, que foi indicado por Renan Calheiros para ser o relator do projeto do abuso de autoridade, disse que incluiu na proposta muitas das sugestões do procurador-geral da República, Rodrigo Janot, e que recebe críticas de quem não quer ser punido pelos abusos que comete.
Delegados,
procuradores e juízes estão preocupados principalmente com dois
pontos do projeto. Um autoriza advogados dos acusados a pedir a
abertura de processo por abuso de autoridade contra eles, por
exemplo, por prenderem um suspeito. E o outro permite que juízes e
procuradores sejam punidos por interpretar a lei.
A
senadora Ana Amélia, do Partido Progressista, também questionou em
plenário a mudança de Requião.
“Agora,
nessa questão específica da interpretação, a resposta de vossa
excelência ainda não me deixou suficientemente tranquila em
relação aos riscos que a Lava Jato corre, sim”, disse a senadora
Ana Amélia (PP-RS).
O
senador Álvaro Cias criticou o discurso de Renan Calheiros. “Esse
não é o momento de questionar a conduta de investigadores e
julgadores. Este é o momento de questionar a conduta dos agentes
públicos que praticaram a corrupção”, apontou o senador Alvaro
Dias (PV-PR), líder do partido.
A
aprovação de uma lei que puna juízes por interpretação da lei
também preocupa ministros do Supremo.
O
ministro Marco
Aurélio Mello
disse que a hermenêutica - a interpretação da lei - é parte
fundamental do trabalho dos magistrados.
“Nós
não temos crime hermenêutico, pela interpretação dada pelo juiz,
pelo órgão investido do ofício judicante”, disse Marco Aurélio,
ministro do STF.
Ao
ser perguntado sobre punição para juiz que interpreta a lei:
“Certamente, eu iria para o paredão”.
tópicos:
veja também
06/05/2016
12/04/2017
THE END
Comments on this article Report inappropriate comments